banner.gif (3613 Byte)

Corner.gif 1x1.gif Corner.gif
1x1.gif You are at: Home - Discussion Forum 1x1.gif
Corner.gif 1x1.gif Corner.gif
round_corner_upleft.gif (837 Byte) 1x1.gif (807 Byte) round_corner_upright.gif (837 Byte)

Go Back   Gordon Lightfoot Forums > Small Talk

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 01-28-2007, 09:28 AM   #1
Auburn Annie
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Upstate New York
Posts: 3,113

O Canada! We pen great songs

Glorious and free, this gift of ours for telling stories in three minutes. By Greg Quill

January 28, 2007
We are a nation of songwriters.

More than any other art form, the song has for generations been the thing Canadians make best.

It could even be argued that the simple song provides the common language that binds and illuminates the nation more richly and completely than any other of our cultural endeavours in literature, film, drama, symphonic music, opera and even the visual arts.

Songs are everywhere in this country, in every nook and cranny. Pop songs, traditional songs, art songs, rock and country songs – everything from Ian and Sylvia to the Arcade Fire – have, since the great surge of cultural nationalism in the 1960s, been our most popular and passionate form of self-expression.

So it's no surprise that the Canadian Songwriters Hall Of Fame annual event has, in four short years, become the focus of national pride. The brainchild of veteran music publisher Frank Davies, the gala induction ceremony in Toronto – this year's honoree, Joni Mitchell, will be feted tonight at the John Bassett Theatre with performances by James Taylor and Chaka Khan and a presentation by famed U.S. composer Herbie Hancock – now looms so large on the musical calendar that it threatens to overshadow the industry's more established horse race, the Junos.

The absence of a business agenda and political manoeuverings elevate the Songwriters gala to the status of a generous and benign national celebration of song craft and the Canadian identity. There are no losers, only winners, and lots of great music to enjoy – much of it being repatriated for the first time and lacking a lasting place on commercial radio playlists.

Canadians know about hitmakers like Paul Anka and Neil Young. But there were countless Canadian songwriters from decades earlier – the creators of still-instantly-recognizable songs like "Tumbling Tumbleweeds" to "Ain't We Got Fun" to "What A Friend We Have in Jesus" – whose names have faded from memory. As long as there has been popular music, Canadians have been writing it and writing it well.

Of course, for many contemporary songwriters, the benchmarks were set during the golden age of the 1960s and '70s, when Mitchell, Leonard Cohen, Gordon Lightfoot, Young, Ian and Sylvia Tyson, Bruce Cockburn and countless others reached the world music market with songs that were distinctly and unself-consciously Canadian.

"A disproportionate number of Canadian songwriters have touched the world," says Toronto composer John Capek, an Australian expat whose songs have been recorded by the likes of Rod Stewart, Diana Ross, Joe Cocker, Cher, Olivia Newton-John, Heart, and Manhattan Transfer.

"Canada has produced hit songwriters going back 100 years. But before the folk era and the emergence of Canadian story songs, they had to go to the States to get work and recognition."

Our songwriters owe a lot to Yorkville, Toronto's music crucible in the 1960s and '70s, says Vancouver-based roots/pop composer Joel Kroeker.

"What made Canadian songwriters different after that – for me, at least – was the quality of their stories. They looked into their own psyches to find universal feelings and ideas that others shared.

"It's too easy to go with the first rhyme that pops into your head. There's nothing superficial about Leonard's lyrics, or Joni's. They often went into very dark places in their souls to find a poetic view of life. That's the standard I hold myself to."

Acclaimed songwriter Ron Hynes, based in St. John's, says, "It's almost second nature for us to document ourselves in song. We've been doing it for hundreds of years, long before there was a music industry. Songs were written – still are, as far as I'm concerned – to document who and where people were and what happened to them. In Canada, if you scratch a lawyer, a doctor or an Indian chief, they'll tell you, `I wrote a song once.'

"Some songs become so entrenched that they simply move like the air from generation to generation. `Four Strong Winds' (written by Ian Tyson in 30 minutes in his manager's New York apartment in the early 1960s) defines the Canadian West. And the beautiful thing is, like so many great Canadian songs, it defies the conventions ... the chorus has the same melody as the verses, there's no bridge, no artificial construction. It's the native approach ..."

Respect for the traditions in Canadian song craft is paramount for her, says Juno-winning roots/country songwriter Jenny Whiteley, of the prolific musical clan.

"The writers who first amazed me – particularly Willie P. Bennett and Robbie Robertson, and my dad – all tapped into the older idioms, whether rural American music, southern ballads, blues and jazz, that embodied storytelling. They could tell a whole story, create a life or a character in a three-minute song."

Whiteley believes Canadian songwriters are motivated by factors beyond fame and wealth.

"If you look at the work of Barney Bentall, Tom Cochrane, Jim Cuddy, Stephen Fearing, Gord Downie and so many others, you can see it's not just the hit song they're going for, it's something bigger, something nearer the truth. Their bullshit detectors are all working. That may have something to do with peer respect, or an awareness of the work already out there."

Toronto songwriter Ron Sexsmith, on the phone from his tour bus in Colorado, says this high standard of songwriting is "a tradition I'm always trying to uphold. So many of the most influential songwriters in the history of popular music are Canadian. I'm constantly reminded of that. It's a matter of national pride."

Raised in St. Catharines, Ont., Sexsmith – whose songs are openly adored by fellow pros ranging from Steve Earle to Coldplay's Chris Martin – started out wanting to be a pop star in a rock band. He remembers being unimpressed by the famous 1960s National Film Board documentary on Cohen when it was screened at school, dismissing the Montreal troubadour as "a poet who couldn't sing."

But a few years later, when he was exposed to full-blown Cohen-mania during a stint in Quebec, he listened again and the experience changed him forever.

"It made me want to be a songwriter, not just another musician," says Sexsmith.

"It's the standards set by those guys – and Joni Mitchell, and k.d. lang – that I try to reach. Everything they write has such a distinctive personal stamp. They're not writing for the marketplace.

"Those are the standards every songwriter I know in Canada tries to live up to. You hear that respect in the work of (Toronto composers) Bob Snider, Kyp Harness and Sam Larkin, writers who have their own way of saying what they need to."

Nova Scotia rocker Joel Plaskett, who seems poised to crack the international music market in the near future, believes migration and isolation have a lot to do with the unique quality of Canadian songs.

"Immigrants brought their music from Scotland and Ireland and Europe," he says. "And those origins are reflected in the melodies and song forms of each region of the country. They've stayed with us, partly because they connect people to their past. But also, I think, because our songs give us both a real sense of place and time and some kind of collective sensibility.

"The first time I played in Glasgow (Scotland), I felt as if I'd gone home. Everything was so familiar to me – the people even looked like Nova Scotians, and songs gave us a common language. We understood each other through songs.

"You could make an argument that climate and distance make a difference as well. The sense of aloneness, the need to connect can be pretty acute in most small Canadian communities. So details are important in a lot of Canadian songs, as personal points of reference. We also have a lot of time indoors during the winter. We read, we make music, we think a lot about ourselves and our circumstances."

Big landscapes, long winters and endless roads are consistent elements in the songs of Alberta roustabout Corb Lund, who will sing the late Wilf Carter into the Songwriters Hall of Fame tonight with a performance of the 1940s country star's signature song, "There's a Love Knot in My Lariat."

"Climate and distance are things we deal with in a lot in our songs," Lund says. "Canadians are generally more artistically inclined when writing songs, I guess because we're so far from the centres of the commercial music business in America. We don't necessarily think about writing hit songs ... more about writing songs that communicate.

"Communication is what motivates me. I'm a natural introvert, so songs give me a platform and instant feedback when I play them."

The focus shifts slightly when it comes to writing pop songs, says Carl Newman of Vancouver's New Pornographers, on the phone from his home in Brooklyn, N.Y.

"What makes Canadian bands great is they go about their work quietly. Arcade Fire is one of the best bands in the world, but they're humble people with good heads. You could say that about Blue Rodeo, the Tragically Hip, Barenaked Ladies."

In pop, motivation often comes down to keeping up with the Joneses, Newman says, "the way the Stones did with the Beatles, and the Beatles with Brian Wilson.

"But for me it's always the song that comes first. I'll hand over a song to (vocalist) Neko (Case) if she can make it better.

"That's not a decision most performers would make. And it makes me a Canadian songwriter, I guess ..."
Auburn Annie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-28-2007, 10:32 AM   #2
DJ in MJ
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Moose Jaw, SK
Posts: 331

Thanks Annie, that was a great article. Humble as we are, that list of names still leaves me awestruck!
DJ in MJ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-28-2007, 10:59 AM   #3
Join Date: May 2000
Posts: 15,586

The fellow who wrote the piece above is an entertainment writer - music section/folk/roots etc. for the TORONTO STAR. Originally from Australia he has been here for years and years and is himself a wonderful singer/songwriter/performer. He has performed at Hugh's Room where the Lightfoot Tribute shows are held and all over the city and Toronto area at different venues.

It's nice that this was written by someone other than a Canuck trying to toot our horn.

Greg Quill is an Entertainment Columnist with the Toronto Star, Canada’s largest daily newspaper. For most of the past 20 years, he has written a lot about music, and for the last five years, almost exclusively about roots music in its various forms – folk, country, blues, world music, rhythm ‘n’ blues, country-rock, folk-rock, gospel, art song and pure balladry.

He is also a singer and a songwriter, first in Australia, where his love of traditional music was nurtured in the 1960s and 70s with the award-winning band Country Radio, and then in Canada. Greg performs regularly on the folk club and festival circuit in Canada and Australia, both solo and with his band The Usual Suspects. For more information:

I'd have to agree with everything he wrote - the amazing songwriters we have is astounding..they tell stories of the people, the geography, politics, the industries in this country, mingled with stories of relationships, love, loss, family, history...all the things that Lightfoot writes and sings about yet each is so individual in their revelations that their story of a sinking ship, a train, or a lost love makes you appreciate all of the others you've heard before but yet not compare them as they were the inspiration for the new ones.

They are humble stories from humble people driven to tell what they's not the bottom line for so many of's a need to communicate, to connect, to make even a small impact on those who listen...that is teir legacy, their drive.

I've just rec'd my tix to finally see Ron Sexsmith in May...I hope to see Aengus and Jory in March, possibly that Lightfoot fellow again..and any others I am blessed enough to be able to connect with this year.

Hugh's Room offers these artists a most glorious place to be heard..there are many, many other spots in and around Toronto as I'm sure there are places all across Canada, fostering and encouraging the storytellers of yesterday, today and those who will come next to continue to write and get onstage and perform the songs of our lives.

Attending the Lightfoot Tribute shows has opened me up to numerous songwriters/performers that take the stage. While I listen to them sing Lightfoot tunes I have also become a fan of their own creations...I now have CD's that are not just listed in the "Lightfoot" section of my CD rack...!

Because of Lightfoot music these artists were inspired to put themselves out there with their own stories, in their own style, and because of Lightfoot I have been exposed to these Canadian songwriters who have enriched my life.

Here's to the Canadian songwriter!
charlene is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-28-2007, 11:32 AM   #4
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: ontario, canada
Posts: 5,272

great article and follow up thoughts, thanks a bunch!

i think it's a per capita thing, there's alot of downtime in the dark, cold, winter to put the creative mind to focus..the geography and inferiority thing adds a flavour also ...i know there's tons of hidden gem writers ALL across north america and overseas but may get pressured to write to try appeal to the masses more if they want to land 'that' deal...folks who post here kno w, hear and and see these very type of artists in all pockets of the world but it's so rare something launched them to notoriety, they are more respected amongst their peers than anything

i think the climate warps the brain into a creative mode also...i imagine that global warming may dry up the well!
jj is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
CBC Songwriter show is up! charlene General Discussion 21 02-12-2019 01:33 AM
What about favourite female singer songwriter? Canadian or other!!! Jesse Joe Small Talk 36 04-02-2007 04:13 PM
new pic from songwriter gala charlene General Discussion 16 02-11-2005 11:12 PM
Hey everyone! I'm trying to find out something,.. Luvs2play General Discussion 12 09-17-2004 01:51 PM
A songwriter on songwriting Auburn Annie Small Talk 5 04-02-2004 12:34 PM

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
downleft 1x1.gif (807 Byte) downright