Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul Farnham
I think a good portion of the disappointment some folks experience in regard to Gord's recent vocal performances stems from the fact that he raised the bar so high in his prime. You never hear anyone say "Geez, that Bob Dylan sure doesn't sing as well as he used to!"
|
I'm sure that might be true with some. But, if you read my posts about the Milwaukee show or posts of others beside the thread starter, you would know that the comments weren't from people who hadn't seen him recently and couldn't put it in proper context.
I don't expect 1970s Gordon. And, I don't think I could have been clearer that I was comparing this show to shows of just a year or two ago, not shows from his prime. I pretty much mentioned that in every post. As I noted, I wouldn't have written anything if folks who weren't there hadn't explained that the original poster didn't know what he was talking about. I agree with all of you that the original review was harsh, and somewhat unfair, but his voice was significantly weaker in Milwaukee than in RECENT concerts. This isn't a slam and it doesn't mean I think any less of the man. It just is.
I understand that it is typical on a fan board to be defensive over the performer we are all here to enjoy. But, that doesn't mean those who thought he was somewhat off don't have proper context. It just means he had a bad night, and likely was feeling a bit under the weather. That happens to the best of them.
Tim - I'm glad he had a good performance In Aurora. I saw him there a couple of years ago and had a blast. Great show and a fun night out.