GG1 (1975). I've said this elsewhere in this forum, but I'll say it again. Arranger/conductor Lee Holdredge was responsible for the string arrangements on album 1 of GL's UA re-makes. Gord and HIS band are their usual enjoyable selves. But every tune is top-heavy with strings. During this time, John Denver was at the height of his popularity as well. Holdredge did Denver's string arrangements as well. What worked well for Denver didn't work as well for Lightfoot. Denver's music was supported by those heavy string arrangements while Lightfoot's work was nearly buried by them. Also take note that Holdredge never worked with Lightfoot again.
GG2 (1980's). With the exception of "High and Dry", nearly every tune on this LP pales by comparison to the originals. Gone is Nick DeCaro's concertina on "Christian Island". Gone is Peewee Charles' steel on nearly every tune. The only worth this album holds for me is "I'ts Worth Belevin'" is on CD, and the newly recorded "If It Should Please You".
------------------
|