Gordon Lightfoot Forums

Gordon Lightfoot Forums (http://www.corfid.com/vbb//index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://www.corfid.com/vbb//forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best? (http://www.corfid.com/vbb//showthread.php?t=23163)

dad2mak 01-26-2011 11:51 PM

Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I thought it might be fun to ask this question of the group...

Which Lightfoot do you like the best? Here are my (arbitrary) categories:

1. The wandering minstrel/troubador (Lightfoot–Red Shea-John Stockfish)

2. The countrified Lightfoot (Lightfoot–Pee Wee Charles–Rick Haynes–Terry Clemens)

3. The pop singer Lightfoot (Lightfoot–Rick Haynes–Terry Clemens–Mike Hefernan–Barry Keane)

4. The elder stateman Lightfoot (the current guys and most recent songs)

I'll be interested in the posts to come.

joveski 01-27-2011 12:07 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
personally like the 1970-1985 period the best

2silent2breal 01-27-2011 12:11 AM

Let me be the first to cop out.
All of the above:clap:

banjobench12 01-27-2011 12:16 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
Definitely #2 but I think there were a few years where there was Pee Wee but also Barry. That was the best configuration, in my view

Lisa J 01-27-2011 12:19 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I like his look and his voice during the 70's and 80's, but the Gord of today is a joy to see in concert. The way he interacts with the fans makes us feel as if we know him. He really seems to enjoy this phase of his career. As for his music, I think he has always written fabulous songs, so no time period outshines another in my mind. The old songs are great, but songs like "Clouds of Loneliness" and "Sometimes I Wish" are among his best.

curiousmoonbeam 01-27-2011 08:41 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
For vocals I think the "Gord's Gold" era was the best. As for songwriting I also feel that he has been strong throughout his career. He seemed to have struggled with it, though, in that it caused him a great deal of isolation. Just as a side note, just read Ian Tyson's "The Long Trail" and I think his writing is a refuge to him - just my humble opinion. Actually meeting Gord, our poet genius last October, although for just a few minutes and getting an autograph, was absolutely awsome. Won't make the Hershey concert but hope to see him at Jim Thorpe in the fall. Kind of got off the track. Blessings to you all!

charlene 01-27-2011 08:51 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I got Tyson's book for Christmas and found that he took his writing and music as refuge and his horses/ranching as his life..and sadly, both seemed to overtake his relationships with everyone he was close to. I found a lot of the book quite sad yet the joy he derived from his ranch and horses/rodeo life was quite apparent. He's a no bullcrap realist and it was nice to read about his life written in such a bluntly realistic and truthful way.

formerlylavender 01-27-2011 10:08 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?

BILLW 01-27-2011 10:56 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
Maybe it's #1+ or #2- but epitomized by the Don Quixote era? The time he describes (perhaps) in APPT when he sings:

"I was in my stride, always at my game
Here comes mister cool, along the walk of fame
I was in demand, always in control
The world was in my hands, my touch had turn to gold
Once upon a time, I was in a daze when
I was in my prime, once along the way"

Bill :)

jj 01-27-2011 11:22 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
1b) 1970

Gord, Rick, Red, Terry


ie. no drums, no pedal steel, no keyboards... just tasty pickin' and a simple groove (oh, and some pretty decent vocals:) )

dad2mak 01-27-2011 01:52 PM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I wonder how many picked the Lightfoot they liked best as the Lightfoot they were first introduced to?

I was first introduced to Lightfoot by a girl I was dating who lived in Santa Ana CA named Jeannie Merrit. She played me the "Did She Mention My Name" album, and I was hooked for life. So that's my favorite GL, the one who wrote "Did She Mention My Name," "Mountains and Maryann," "Wherefore and Why."

And that was my first GL concert too, Gordon, Red Shea, and Rick Haynes at the Santa Monica Civic Auditorium in 1969. 3rd row center, aisle seat.

2silent2breal 01-27-2011 03:02 PM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
Despite copping out earlier in the thread, I really do have an opinion here. Count me among the 1's with a sprinkling of 2. The first album I purchased was Summer Side of Life and I wore it down completely to the point that I needed to purchase it again two years later. I still marvel at the number of unbelievably good songs the man wrote between the late 60's and mid to late 70's and how well those songs have held up over the years. His voice during that period was perfect for the songs he sings. Instrumentally, I favor acoustic but also think Pee Wee's steel complimented the arrangements perfectly.

redhead 01-28-2011 12:30 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
With his music being consistently good for so many years, my favorite period in his evolution keeps changing and largely depends on my mood at the time.

Regarding the man himself, I adore the kind and humble persona he now carries with him. He consistently comes across as such a kind and decent man; humble and nice.

I like "nice".:)

BendRick 01-28-2011 01:13 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
Everything from Summer Side of Life to Summertime Dream, with the additions of Shadows and Songbook.

Shutup and Deal, I'm Losin' 02-12-2011 01:48 PM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I go through spells where I'll like the 60's Lightfoot, then I usually skip ahead to the 80's Lightfoot, then the current Lightfoot (1993 and up) then I'll usually fall back in love with the 1970's.

Just as it's hard to choose a favorite song because your preferences can change, so it is when choosing an 'era' of Gord.

Wes Steele 02-12-2011 07:01 PM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
Wow, what a great question.... one of the best here on Corfid.

I liked reading all of your comments also. Very good. You all brought out some interesting points and I agree with all of you.

There are good points in all categories. I have favorites from each one.

GL has given my family great joy through the years. It is neat to see my 14 year old boy and his friend listen to his songs constantly. GL's songs ARE timeless.

I have great memories from each category. I have been patient lately and hung around after the show to meet him and that has been unbelievable for me. Like a number of you said, he is very humble....but very relaxed these past years.

There have been times in the past where GL has seemed apprehensive on stage, though he sounded great. There must have been a lot of pressure on him, whether it was personal or business....But everytime I saw him, he sounded great on stage.

GL has helped me through out my life with his music. And if you have been able to study him closely through the years, you can learn from him. I have... and I am still learning from him.

bjm7777 02-12-2011 09:58 PM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
1975 to 1985...1980 to 83 as the favorite....

brink- 02-13-2011 02:01 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
#1 easing into #2 are my favorites......can't pick just one! But as Lisa said, I really like the friendly Gord version that we have now.

niffer 02-13-2011 11:02 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
While it almost goes without saying that you can't really go wrong with whichever era you choose, I always seem to go back to the songs from 1970-76. Six of my personal Top Ten are from this period. Although when I think about it, that's only 60%. It just shows how much there is to choose from.
I generally listen to the very early songs the least, but whenever I do, I am always amazed at the power and clarity of his voice.
And having had the great privilege to talk with him in the past few years, I too am thrilled with what a gracious person he is. "Nice" is good.

David 02-15-2011 09:17 AM

Re: Which Lightfoot Do You Like Best?
I'll approach this from the opposite direction. My least favourite period, which is still better than 95% of anything else that's out there, would be mid-80s to late 90s (East of Midnight to Painter). This period is good, but everything else before and after is absolutely stellar.

It can also come down to the day and whatever mood fancies me. With artists who have been around for awhile, sometimes I want early, sometimes middle, sometimes late.

Today? Too early; haven't decided yet. :)

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:32 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.