Showdown ... of a different sort

[mercedes]

Dear Members ...

If this question has been posed before, forgive me .....

What I'd like to know by vote is this .... if you were compelled (God forbid) to choose either of the following CDs (the other you would have to permanently surrender) which one would you keep .... and why ....

"Gord's Gold Vol 1" or
"Complete Greatest Hits" ?

Mike

[Cathy]

Gord's Gold. Not that it's any better. I like Complete Greatest Hit's almost as much. But Gord's Gold was the first Lightfoot album I owned, and I played it until it was completely worn out. I bought the 8 track, the cassette, and now I'm on my 2nd CD, having worn everything completely out. I smartened up this time, though. I made a CDR of my new Gord's Gold CD and put the new one away for safe keeping.

[Borderstone]

"Complete Greatest Hits" (I can always find G.G. again.) This one being newer,very soon,it may be hard to find for awhile.

[Molly]

Gord's Gold, I like the complete greatest hits. But Gord's Gold just, I don't know, just strikes me as more of a Gord project and he made it the way he wanted it. Anybody can have a greatest hits.

[byKimberly]

Complete Greatest Hits, because I don't like some of the other versions of songs on the GG.
Kimberly

[Cathy]

Originally posted by someday:
I would have to vote for Complete Greatest Hits for the same reason as Cathy. What? Didn't I vote for Gord's Gold?

[mercedes]

Cathy

Yep, you did ....

I'll take the blame for that as I might have framed the original question in more straightforward terms.

[BILLW]

Gord's Gold since it contains some different versions. If you have every other Lightfoot album then you already have all the 'greatest hits', no ? So you could lose that one and never miss a beat.

Bill :)

[Cathy]

Originally posted by someday:
quote:Originally posted by Cathy:
quote:Originally posted by someday:
I would have to vote for Complete Greatest Hits for the same reason as Cathy. What? Didn't I vote for Gord's Gold? [/QUOTE]What I meant was Complete Greatest Hits was also the first Gord CD I owned... I wore it out and listened to it until it crapped out and skipped on several songs. Then I bought a new one. [/QUOTE]Yeah, I did that, too. But I've smartened up in the past few years. Now I make copies and play those.

[SilverHeels]

I think 'Gord Gold' - the sleeve pic is to die for, right ? But 'Greatest Hits' was given me as a 'making up' present so that one has sentimental value ... geeez, this *is* difficult!
Make it easier next time, Mike!
:D

[mercedes]

Make it easier ?? That's why I posed the question .... I certainly can't pick between the two, particularly when by my own (hypothetical) rules, I have to cut times with one of them altogether. :D