Favorite Lightfoot Song & Why? II

[<.>]

the pony man has always been one of my favorites. It's what got me started into listening to Gord. i also like bells of the evening, carefree highway, the ecmond fitzgerald, and softly.

[unapKnill]

Wow. Favorite Gordon song is not the easiest choice in the world. I would have to say its a coin flip between "Cherokee Bend" and "Now and Then". Now and then is just an amazing piece all the way around, especially his vocal usage during the song, and Cherokee Bend, I don't know, Ive just always been really into that song. Maybe its because it's often overlooked in Gordon lore with all the other great tunes he has put out. But anyways, thats as close as I can narrow it down.

[Kenmorr23]

Wow. Favorite Gordon song is not the easiest choice in the world. I would have to say its a coin flip between "Cherokee Bend" and "Now and Then". Now and then is just an amazing piece all the way around, especially his vocal usage during the song, and Cherokee Bend, I don't know, Ive just always been really into that song. Maybe its because it's often overlooked in Gordon lore with all the other great tunes he has put out. But anyways, thats as close as I can narrow it down.

[Chris Castleberry]

Rainbow Trout.

[Borderstone]

Hey Chris,that's one of my favorites too. Although quite a short song,I love the storybook simplicity of "Rainbow Trout". Not to mention that I can sing along with it easily. :)

[Chris Castleberry]

Originally posted by Borderstone:
Hey Chris,that's one of my favorites too. Although quite a short song,I love the storybook simplicity of "Rainbow Trout". Not to mention that I can sing along with it easily. :) Oh, yeah... It's one of those songs that's made great by Gords voice, not his guitar picking. :)

[<Wendy>]

My favorite Lightfoot song... very difficult to choose!! I do love "Beautiful" and "Song for a Winter's Night". If I have to pick one and only one it would be "Fine as Fine Can Be". Here's the story: My first Gordon Lightfoot concert was in the summer of 1979, in RI right at the ocean, and I was expecting my first child. The concert was great until he had to stop playing because the air was so damp that it was going to ruin his guitar. Anyway, that fall she was born and last year she danced with dad to that song at her wedding. It was a most perfect moment!

[<Wendy>]

My favorite Lightfoot song... very difficult to choose!! I do love "Beautiful" and "Song for a Winter's Night". If I have to pick one and only one it would be "Fine as Fine Can Be". Here's the story: My first Gordon Lightfoot concert was in the summer of 1979, in RI right at the ocean, and I was expecting my first child. The concert was great until he had to stop playing because the air was so damp that it was going to ruin his guitar. Anyway, that fall she was born and last year she danced with dad to that song at her wedding. It was a most perfect moment!

[Sydney Steve]

What a lovely story Wendy - now that is in itself worthy of a song ... that fall she was born and last year she danced with dad to that song at her wedding. You have warmed some hearts (but dampened some tissues), many of the inhabitants in this website are incorrigible romantics...

Your sentiments (while "Beautiful"), have probably contributed to some tears too...

[ October 21, 2005, 07:50: Message edited by: Sydney Steve ]

[DeeDee aka fairydrum]

For reasons I posted in a thread I just started, "Beautiful" is my favorite song. It is just a truly "Beautiful" song that seemed to perfectly describe my love for my wife some 26+ years ago when we were engaged.

As I noted in my post, "Beautiful" touched me so much, that I had a talented singer friend of mine perform it as our last dance at our wedding reception some 26 years ago next week. I can't wait to hear the man perform it himself tomorrow evening in Boston.

[BarryS]

For reasons I posted in a thread I just started, "Beautiful" is my favorite song. It is just a truly "Beautiful" song that seemed to perfectly describe my love for my wife some 26+ years ago when we were engaged.

As I noted in my post, "Beautiful" touched me so much, that I had a talented singer friend of mine perform it as our last dance at our wedding reception some 26 years ago next week. I can't wait to hear the man perform it himself tomorrow evening in Boston.

[Sheryl]

Tomorrow evening in Boston, eh? I know you'll have a great time, Barry. Meanwhile, back in Los Angeles, I will be at the Eagles concert at the Staples Center. They're not Gord... but, pretty darned good!

[mercedes]

.... and Sheryl, I hope they sing what is (IMHO) the best song of the new millenium thus far ... "Hole in the World".

[Sheryl]

Ended up with really bad cold, so I won't be going to the Eagles. Well, I still have their greatest hits on CD. That'll have to suffice. &lt;sigh&gt;

[mnmouse]

Originally posted by Mike Dixon:
.... and Sheryl, I hope they sing what is (IMHO) the best song of the new millenium thus far ... "Hole in the World". Mike, you are spot on about that one. I was listening to the Eagles on Friday in my car, and thinking this was one of the best songs I have heard in a very long time.

[DeeDee aka fairydrum]

I am also a huge Eagles fan who would jump at the chance to see them again. Next time they head back to New England, maybe.

But tonight it's Gordon Lightfoot, and I'm psyched. I've been playing the Gord's Gold CD the past few days getting ready for tonight.

[BarryS]

I am also a huge Eagles fan who would jump at the chance to see them again. Next time they head back to New England, maybe.

But tonight it's Gordon Lightfoot, and I'm psyched. I've been playing the Gord's Gold CD the past few days getting ready for tonight.

[jannie]

I'm a longtime Gord fan. My favorite song is the Canadian Railroad Trilogy because it speaks so much to his country's history. I've never been to Canada yet but many of his tunes have inspired me to go. Of course, I absolutely love a lot of his other songs too numerous to mention right now for this Louisiana sleepyhead. G'nite yall.

[strapper]

I'm a longtime Gord fan. My favorite song is the Canadian Railroad Trilogy because it speaks so much to his country's history. I've never been to Canada yet but many of his tunes have inspired me to go. Of course, I absolutely love a lot of his other songs too numerous to mention right now for this Louisiana sleepyhead. G'nite yall.

[jannie]

....I couldn't sleep so I'm back with my #2 and #3 selections...drum roll please! My #2 Christian Island and #3 The Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald...I'll round out my top ten but have to give it some serious thought. I just love the melody of the sea ballad Christian Island plain and simple. As for 'Fitz' its simply a classic song and has to be on anybody's short list of his best work. I bought the new CD Harmony and I find myslef singing about the No Tell Motel a lot but the title song is great too.

[strapper]

....I couldn't sleep so I'm back with my #2 and #3 selections...drum roll please! My #2 Christian Island and #3 The Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald...I'll round out my top ten but have to give it some serious thought. I just love the melody of the sea ballad Christian Island plain and simple. As for 'Fitz' its simply a classic song and has to be on anybody's short list of his best work. I bought the new CD Harmony and I find myslef singing about the No Tell Motel a lot but the title song is great too.

[myk]

My favorite song is It's Worth Believin'. It is hard to pinpoint only one thing that makes this song my favorite. From a broader perspective, it makes me think back to a close, romantic relationship I had with a girl in college. We were very much in love and talked about marriage and having children someday. For various reasons, our love for each other slowly faded over the years, and we parted ways. I think that this song brings back those feelings that you have for a person that you are deeply in love with but are nearing the end of the road of your time together on earth. There isn't any one thing that causes the breakup, it's something that happens slowly over time. Then it builds to the point like described in this song, where you and the other person are just so disconnected and you wonder how something that was once so good got to be so bad.

This song brings up the very sad and empty feeling that you get in your heart at such a time when you start to realize that you won't ever be with this person again in the same capacity. I think that this is the most difficult aspect about parting ways with a loved one...realizing your future without them. You may fall in love and be in a much more fulfilling relationship again, but you will never be with that same person again.

This song is like a bag of pine needles that I used to have in my bureau drawer as a child and still have to this day. Thirty years later I find myself holding that bag to my nose and smelling the familiar smell of pine and being transported back to a different time in my life. That's what Gordon's songs, especially this one, do for me.

[<Lisa>]

The Way I Feel...What a great song...I have
been listening to Gordon Lightfoot since I was
10.

[<Lisa>]

The Way I Feel...What a great song...I have
been listening to Gordon Lightfoot since I was
10.

[pat murphy]

Is this a question that can be answered? I first heard Lightfoot back in 1970 and was captivated from the start. So that's 35 years of listening to and hearing his words, music, and voice. It would almost be easier to say this is my favorite song from...and go through each album.

Without pulling out albums, or CDs, or looking at a discography, I've thought of two immediately though. The first is "Affair on 8th Avenue". It's haunting. The second is "Whisper My Name", although I'm not sure why since parts of seem almost like "bubblegum".

Yet now I'm thinking about "Heaven Help the Devil" and "If You Need Me" and....

How fortunate to grow up listening to Joni Mitchell and Gordon Lightfoot, and have them joined by Jackson Browne, Paul Simon, and so many others. It was all worth it.

tara

[fairychick]

Is this a question that can be answered? I first heard Lightfoot back in 1970 and was captivated from the start. So that's 35 years of listening to and hearing his words, music, and voice. It would almost be easier to say this is my favorite song from...and go through each album.

Without pulling out albums, or CDs, or looking at a discography, I've thought of two immediately though. The first is "Affair on 8th Avenue". It's haunting. The second is "Whisper My Name", although I'm not sure why since parts of seem almost like "bubblegum".

Yet now I'm thinking about "Heaven Help the Devil" and "If You Need Me" and....

How fortunate to grow up listening to Joni Mitchell and Gordon Lightfoot, and have them joined by Jackson Browne, Paul Simon, and so many others. It was all worth it.

tara

[<Devil's Refugee>]

It has to be If you could read my mind.
Our first exposure to Gordon 3 years ago, and certainly not the last

[<Devil's Refugee>]

It has to be If you could read my mind.
Our first exposure to Gordon 3 years ago, and certainly not the last

[Robert Shortell]

My favorite gl song was edmund fitzgerald-yes, the rest were good-but kind of reminded me of the music machine...I next heard Race among the ruins-and its my favorite now-its easy to sing harmony to & easy to play...lol....namaste & blessings gordon!!!

[pat murphy]

My favorite gl song was edmund fitzgerald-yes, the rest were good-but kind of reminded me of the music machine...I next heard Race among the ruins-and its my favorite now-its easy to sing harmony to & easy to play...lol....namaste & blessings gordon!!!

[Robert Shortell]

My favorite song was Edmund Fitz.-but then later I heard Race among the ruins-Wow!!...easy to harmonize to, and easy to play-thank you gordon for the songs-namaste & blessings, patricia in tenn.

[pat murphy]

My favorite song was Edmund Fitz.-but then later I heard Race among the ruins-Wow!!...easy to harmonize to, and easy to play-thank you gordon for the songs-namaste & blessings, patricia in tenn.

[Scarlet_Witch]

Well, It's great just to be able chat about Gordon and his songs. For me, there are too many, plus I feel there are three distinct era's for him (Before 76, 76-85 and post 85).
For me:

Pre 76: Circle Of Steel
76-85: I'm Not Supposed To Care
Post 85: I'll Prove My Love

Like I said, there's really not any song he's done that I dislike and too many to single out one (unless forced to do so---"I'm Not Supposed To Care").

:cool:

[fpcorsair]

Well, It's great just to be able chat about Gordon and his songs. For me, there are too many, plus I feel there are three distinct era's for him (Before 76, 76-85 and post 85).
For me:

Pre 76: Circle Of Steel
76-85: I'm Not Supposed To Care
Post 85: I'll Prove My Love

Like I said, there's really not any song he's done that I dislike and too many to single out one (unless forced to do so---"I'm Not Supposed To Care").

:cool:

[<sjse@sympatico.ca>]

Gordon lightfoot's songs are all great! "If you could Read My Mind" Big Steel Rail" "Early Morning Rain" but "The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald" has to be the best.

It is Musical genius! If you listen closely you can actually hear the waves. "And every man knew as the Captain did too, it was the Witch of November come stealin'".

"Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours?" Some of the greatest lyrics ever written.
Stan

[<sjse@sympatico.ca>]

Gordon lightfoot's songs are all great! "If you could Read My Mind" Big Steel Rail" "Early Morning Rain" but "The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald" has to be the best.

It is Musical genius! If you listen closely you can actually hear the waves. "And every man knew as the Captain did too, it was the Witch of November come stealin'".

"Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours?" Some of the greatest lyrics ever written.
Stan

[vuvuvuuvuv]

Like so many of the others, he has so many great songs that I don't have a favorite. I have a whole bunch of favorites & it just depends on the mood I'm in. I once said that if I was on my death bed & could only hear 1 more song it would be 'Race Among The Ruins', but on "Summertime Dream" alone I like 'I'm Not Supposed To Care', 'Never Too Close' & 'The House You Live In' just as much. All the other songs on the album except 'Protocol', run a close 2nd to those 4, so you might assume "Summertime Dream" was my favorite album (and it was for a long time), but "Summer Side of Life", "Don Quixote", Cold On The Shoulder", & "Shadows" are all just as good & most of his others aren't far behind. So thankful that my son-in-law got me "Songbook" for Christmas. Hard to believe 'Borderstone' got left off his earlier albums - its Mr. Lightfoot at his best.

[wpaladin48]

Like so many of the others, he has so many great songs that I don't have a favorite. I have a whole bunch of favorites & it just depends on the mood I'm in. I once said that if I was on my death bed & could only hear 1 more song it would be 'Race Among The Ruins', but on "Summertime Dream" alone I like 'I'm Not Supposed To Care', 'Never Too Close' & 'The House You Live In' just as much. All the other songs on the album except 'Protocol', run a close 2nd to those 4, so you might assume "Summertime Dream" was my favorite album (and it was for a long time), but "Summer Side of Life", "Don Quixote", Cold On The Shoulder", & "Shadows" are all just as good & most of his others aren't far behind. So thankful that my son-in-law got me "Songbook" for Christmas. Hard to believe 'Borderstone' got left off his earlier albums - its Mr. Lightfoot at his best.

[roynewyerk]

my fav.song is the hiway song, what a melody and
a tune; great songwriting!!!!

[Sydney Steve]

Good taste speckbacke!
I know way less than most posters here about Gord's work but I heard Hi'Way Songs for the first time only 3 months back when listening to "Songbook" for the first time.
It stood out and struck me as a special track.
Under recognised I reckon !

[<JMN>]

I'd say it's a tossup between Sundown and Don Quixote for myself. When I was in college and a media major my first year, I had a film class and wanted to do a mini-movie to the Sundown theme. Always pictured coinciding the beginning lyrics about the satin dress "in a room where you do what you don't confess" with a shot in a seedy strip club, focusing in on a beautiful dancing woman who really shouldn't be there and a man who knows it but goes along with the charade anyway.

I like the story told in Don Quixote. With a close third of Old Dan's Records.

[<JMN>]

I'd say it's a tossup between Sundown and Don Quixote for myself. When I was in college and a media major my first year, I had a film class and wanted to do a mini-movie to the Sundown theme. Always pictured coinciding the beginning lyrics about the satin dress "in a room where you do what you don't confess" with a shot in a seedy strip club, focusing in on a beautiful dancing woman who really shouldn't be there and a man who knows it but goes along with the charade anyway.

I like the story told in Don Quixote. With a close third of Old Dan's Records.

[<Justin>]

Maybe farewell to annabelle, or caberet, or love and maple syrup, or sea of tranquility or seven island suite, or the way i feel.

[<Justin>]

Maybe farewell to annabelle, or caberet, or love and maple syrup, or sea of tranquility or seven island suite, or the way i feel.

[Shutup and Deal, I'm Losin']

Hi'way Songs
Canadian Railroad Trilogy
The Wreck of The Edmun Ditzgerald

[<Paul Revere>]

Approaching Lavender is my favorite. Great rhythm and lyrics. One of those songs which evokes great emotion.

[<Paul Revere>]

Approaching Lavender is my favorite. Great rhythm and lyrics. One of those songs which evokes great emotion.

[Barry Shanley]

I'm relatively new to GL. I owned GG on tape about 20 yrs ago and lost it. I was young and restless and was more into the harder rock. I've mellowed into classical over the years but had some restless moods, like recently. I've found that GL is a perfect fit for me because of the mix he offers and the lyrics are a deep well to draw from. I've ordered all GL's original music cd's and so far I have 7 album's worth. UA,IYCRMM,SD,and SSOL. So far, I'll go with THE LAST TIME I SAW HER when I'm mellow and SEVEN ISLAND SUITE when I'm alittle rowdy...but I reserve the right to change my mind as new cd's pop in my mailbox...unless...IYCRMM? Ahem...Is there anyone out there who envies my situation? I mean...isn't it like being a kid again?

[marc in maine]

I'm relatively new to GL. I owned GG on tape about 20 yrs ago and lost it. I was young and restless and was more into the harder rock. I've mellowed into classical over the years but had some restless moods, like recently. I've found that GL is a perfect fit for me because of the mix he offers and the lyrics are a deep well to draw from. I've ordered all GL's original music cd's and so far I have 7 album's worth. UA,IYCRMM,SD,and SSOL. So far, I'll go with THE LAST TIME I SAW HER when I'm mellow and SEVEN ISLAND SUITE when I'm alittle rowdy...but I reserve the right to change my mind as new cd's pop in my mailbox...unless...IYCRMM? Ahem...Is there anyone out there who envies my situation? I mean...isn't it like being a kid again?

[Auburn Annie]

Welcome, Lightland; you are definitely among friends here.

[Auburn Annie]

Welcome, Lightland; you are definitely among friends here.

[geodeticman]

Welcome Lightland !

I too, love "Seven Island Suite" for its amazing imagery, smell of autumn leaves, still-water bay canoeing (I picture) and walking on the Islands on a day outing with leaves crunching underfoot, and a mauve sunset harkening time to paddle home. That's my "VIEWING" of that songs' musical painting in my mind. It is so many forum members' favourite song, too, followed closely this LP by "The Watchman's Gone".

Good folks in here. I, like u in some ways, was and am completely absorbed by Lightfoot musically since my First album IYCRMM in 1973, followed VERY quickly by Sundown when it came out.

Perhaps it is the fact that I borrowed a friend's older brother's copy of IYCRMM who was in college at the the time, and I, 14 at the time, sophomorically thought "wow ! College music !" .

I was heretofor used to Deep Purple,
Eagles (Still am), Black Sabbath (bllecchhhh), and Iron Butterfly and the like. Lightfoot seemed like an epiphone. Suddenly, girls were "women to rescue" and "fragrances all in my keeping" : ) .

I had very little time to explore the rich tapestries on that borrowed album but love it very much. The first purchased album was Sundown. It was mine ! As such, I listened to his mesmerizing music, lyrics, phraseology, orchestration, etc. through good quality headphones (Old Koss 3 pounders; total sound blockers that were incredible quality ).

You know how you ALWAYS hear more in good headphones ? Perhaps for this reason (I could not afford another LP because I had to split the cost of my track spikes and CC Adidas Country's both for school with my folks) I had the unique oppurtunity to listen after practice in my bedroom to Sundown on the 'phones over and over and mused to myself, truly, "this is incredible music" and " I have NEVER heard anything like this before".

Particularly, as most frequenters of this forum we call corfid know , I rave on and on given a tangential subject to transion to talk of the incredible orchestration and string arrangements on Sundown, and indeed all of his albums in the 70's in this vane.

Other decades for other reasons wonderful. The late great Nick DeCaro had much to do with this, a genius in his own right, but, as you probably know being a FANatic ! - Gordon had considerable input into his own arrangements, and always made a point of respecting the working musician by hiring local union musicians for strings and such.

He, in his own words (paraphrased), has said that his musical education at the now defunct Westlake College of Music in ?L.A. where he studied as I recall music theory, composition, and arrangements, first on the piano, said that this was an invaluable experience he heartily reccomended for young hopefuls.

I think that particular comment came from a guitar player magazine in the late 70's ( I remember seeing him on the cover at the door mag stand at the "Record" store on Pearl Street Mall in downtown Boulder Colorado. In the 70's, that outdoor walking "mall" was a Woodstock part 1.2 of sorts; a real bohemian haven in an already richly diverse college town. Anyway, I digress....

I guess the headphones with Sundown so long my only album...well... 6 months or so... made me keenly aware of every subtle nuance in that album and I would be hard put to pick one of the *easily* 7 top-ten worthy songs on it as a favourite; but easily a favourite album.

Then, came Don Quixote, and at 14 I, having just read an Arthurian novel, fancied myself the man of La Mancha jousting at windmills, serving a King, winning Lady Guinevere, etc. To save the sanity of readers, I will wax on my ex-cogitations of THAT incredible album another day.

But, Lightland, it sounds like you've been bit bad by the GL bug for years like probably most of us in here (I am only a one monther in here ! ) and could wax enthusiastically longer than me ! Please do !

Also, plese know I do not purport anything I say about GL as "fact"; only my understanding or belief. Much simpler to say this once than preface every statement IMHO ! So much to say about GL, and everyone knows so MUCH in this room. Don't underestimate their keen knowledge and rapier wit ! j/k Its a good bunch in here truly.

Again, welcome Lightland !

"Be known as a man who will be candid on questions that do not relate"

- Steve aka geo-man in this room. :)

[Cathy]

Originally posted by Lightland:
I eat, I drink , I dream, I worship , "Gordon Lightfoot". I dare anyone out there, to try to stomp me on information , regarding our beloved musical ,poet genius. In 1969, when I bought my first GL album " Did She Mention My Name", for the only song I knew of him at that time, " Black Day In July". I got hooked , song after song. I taught to myself, this is what real music is supposed to be. And I have never turned back. Thanks Gord, for helping me thru life, with your music. A loyal fan always!!!!!!!!! Welcome aboard. I doubt that anybody will try to stomp you for info. Most of us are in the same boat as you!
Are you, by chance, a guitar player?

[Yves S.]

Just one favorite 'eh? I don't think it's possible (at least for me). So I'll arrange my top 5 in no particular order. Carefree Highway, If you could read my mind, Sundown, The wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald and Cotton Jenny. Ok, now all you deep thinkers and "superfans" are going to rail on me for choosing the biggest hits. Oh well, I like what I like...and I can't list another 15 songs or this post would be lengthy and boring. I recently returned back from the middle east while serving with the USAF. I was playing Gord on the computer and a couple of the young guys walked in and started bugging "Pops" about what he was listening to. I played the first 3 on my list and instantly converted a few new fans. Thats the power of this great songwriter. The ability to reach every age group by great lyrics and catchy tunes. My teenage kids have always enjoyed GL (of course they had to listen while I drove the car, ha,ha,ha). I'm going to my first GL concert this year and can't wait! Hopefully I'll post a first timers reaction to the experience. Thanks all for putting up with this fan. JGT from MI, USA

[JGT]

Just one favorite 'eh? I don't think it's possible (at least for me). So I'll arrange my top 5 in no particular order. Carefree Highway, If you could read my mind, Sundown, The wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald and Cotton Jenny. Ok, now all you deep thinkers and "superfans" are going to rail on me for choosing the biggest hits. Oh well, I like what I like...and I can't list another 15 songs or this post would be lengthy and boring. I recently returned back from the middle east while serving with the USAF. I was playing Gord on the computer and a couple of the young guys walked in and started bugging "Pops" about what he was listening to. I played the first 3 on my list and instantly converted a few new fans. Thats the power of this great songwriter. The ability to reach every age group by great lyrics and catchy tunes. My teenage kids have always enjoyed GL (of course they had to listen while I drove the car, ha,ha,ha). I'm going to my first GL concert this year and can't wait! Hopefully I'll post a first timers reaction to the experience. Thanks all for putting up with this fan. JGT from MI, USA

[GoofyGurl]

If having to choose a favorite, it would have to be "Tattoo" from "Salute".
The melody is so beautiful, and it really shows Gord at the peak of his voice. Listen to the long phrases
he sings on the verses.

[Kelly Davis]

If having to choose a favorite, it would have to be "Tattoo" from "Salute".
The melody is so beautiful, and it really shows Gord at the peak of his voice. Listen to the long phrases
he sings on the verses.

[Yuri]

As many of you have stated, a favorite GL song is just too hard to pin down. But one that haunts me is, and I'm not sure I have the title right, but the oft repeated line "I heard you talking in your sleep..." is the one I would pick if I had to. It used to take me to my knees every time I heard it, back when I was going through a rough patch.

Besides the GL-ness of it, one thing that I thoroughly enjoy about this song is the men's chorus in the background. I'm just fascinated by them.

Is there someone else out there that knows what I'm talking about...

[1010718]

As many of you have stated, a favorite GL song is just too hard to pin down. But one that haunts me is, and I'm not sure I have the title right, but the oft repeated line "I heard you talking in your sleep..." is the one I would pick if I had to. It used to take me to my knees every time I heard it, back when I was going through a rough patch.

Besides the GL-ness of it, one thing that I thoroughly enjoy about this song is the men's chorus in the background. I'm just fascinated by them.

Is there someone else out there that knows what I'm talking about...

[ponyman]

Hard to pick just one...it changes from day to day but right now I would say my favorite is
"If You Could Read My Mind". Just a beautiful, perfect song.

[lynnfromgeorgia]

Hard to pick just one...it changes from day to day but right now I would say my favorite is
"If You Could Read My Mind". Just a beautiful, perfect song.

[report]

Goodness, I just signed up and started reading this thread... 16 pages? I only got through two. Anyway, I hope I'm not copying anybody else's thought, but I've always loved "Pussywillows and Cattails" because of the haunting orchestral background. It's sort of similar to my favorite Elton John song, "Come Down in Time," which also has strings in the background that set such a distinctive mood.

[report]

Goodness, I just signed up and started reading this thread... 16 pages? I only got through two. Anyway, I hope I'm not copying anybody else's thought, but I've always loved "Pussywillows and Cattails" because of the haunting orchestral background. It's sort of similar to my favorite Elton John song, "Come Down in Time," which also has strings in the background that set such a distinctive mood.

[Daylight Matty]

I tried but just can't pick one. A few of my favorites are Ghosts of Cape Horn, Lavender, Song for a Winter's Night, Race Amoung the Ruins, Lazy Morning, The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face, Softly, Affair on Eighth Avenue...I love them all!

[Jennifer]

Really my favorite often depends on my mood, but one of the first songs to come to mind when thinking of a favorite is Early Morning Rain, the original recording. His voice just soars! :)

[Cathy]

Originally posted by 1010718:
As many of you have stated, a favorite GL song is just too hard to pin down. But one that haunts me is, and I'm not sure I have the title right, but the oft repeated line "I heard you talking in your sleep..." is the one I would pick if I had to. It used to take me to my knees every time I heard it, back when I was going through a rough patch.

Besides the GL-ness of it, one thing that I thoroughly enjoy about this song is the men's chorus in the background. I'm just fascinated by them.

Is there someone else out there that knows what I'm talking about... Oh, that's a great song. It's called Talkin' In Your Sleep. According to Rick Haynes, the guys singing in the background are saying, "Take a potato... take a potato... take a potato...
I know, it doesn't make a bit of sense.

Does anyone else hear, "Take a potato"?

[Daylight Matty]

Originally posted by Jennifer:
Really my favorite often depends on my mood, but one of the first songs to come to mind when thinking of a favorite is Early Morning Rain, the original recording. His voice just soars! :) I agree Jen. It depends on my mood and Early Morning Rain is one of my favs too.

[bendalttrrapa]

My favorite song is - for more than 30 years -
'if you could read me mind'It helped me to get over my first love when he made an end to us being together. And still when I listen to this song the tears come into my eyes.

[alma]

My favorite song is - for more than 30 years -
'if you could read me mind'It helped me to get over my first love when he made an end to us being together. And still when I listen to this song the tears come into my eyes.

[cliftongord]

Hmmm, just one?...that's almost impossible to do. 'Sit Down Young Stranger' has been living on my computer for months now, as well as 'Summer Side Of Life'....but i have a loyal fondness for 'The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald'. I got a swat on the rear for throwing a major meltdown in a store over an 8-track tape with that song on it. I was four. since then I have loved that song and Gord forever. I like 'Marie Christine' and 'Ghosts Of Cape Horn' as well. Something about the sea I guess. And in 1997 I was fortunate enough to see Gord in his first ever stop in Great Falls, Montana. It was a GREAT concert and even when he messed up during 'SDYS' it was still a great show....which is my best friend Brandi's favorite song but she quickly forgave him so please Gord come back to Montana!!!!

[SundownKat]

Hmmm, just one?...that's almost impossible to do. 'Sit Down Young Stranger' has been living on my computer for months now, as well as 'Summer Side Of Life'....but i have a loyal fondness for 'The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald'. I got a swat on the rear for throwing a major meltdown in a store over an 8-track tape with that song on it. I was four. since then I have loved that song and Gord forever. I like 'Marie Christine' and 'Ghosts Of Cape Horn' as well. Something about the sea I guess. And in 1997 I was fortunate enough to see Gord in his first ever stop in Great Falls, Montana. It was a GREAT concert and even when he messed up during 'SDYS' it was still a great show....which is my best friend Brandi's favorite song but she quickly forgave him so please Gord come back to Montana!!!!

[Barry Shanley]

So many "favorite" songs to choose from, it just depends on the mood. I want to mention a top ten of mine that's on the Shadows album: Thank You For The Promises. I love the progressions.

[marc in maine]

So many "favorite" songs to choose from, it just depends on the mood. I want to mention a top ten of mine that's on the Shadows album: Thank You For The Promises. I love the progressions.

[Barry Shanley]

Another honorable mention on the great Shadows album: The High Seas. I hum this one so much, people always think I,m hurt!

[marc in maine]

Another honorable mention on the great Shadows album: The High Seas. I hum this one so much, people always think I,m hurt!

[Cathy]

It must be a Maine thing, Marc, because I love that song as well, and I don't even live near the ocean.

[habsfan1]

"mother of a miner's child" doesn't get more real than that

[cliftongord]

"mother of a miner's child" doesn't get more real than that

[Barry Shanley]

"If Children Had Wings" on Endless Wire. It seems to be underrated. It's such a beauty.

[marc in maine]

"If Children Had Wings" on Endless Wire. It seems to be underrated. It's such a beauty.

[Yuri]

Ask an easy Question, why don't you??

My favorite album has to be 'Summer Side of Life' yet my favorite songs are probably some that are most dear to me, yet not so popular and never played live. 'Looking at the Rain' has to have been written about me. I found out that a girl I had been seeing on a regular basis decided one day marry someone else and not let me in on it. Confused, I hopped in my car and drove all night with no destination in mind. It was pouring rain and Gord on the cassette keeping rhythm with the wipers gave me comfort. In 'Looking at the Rain' Gord sings about "a picture frame of lace" which only then struck me as a wedding veil! The entire song summed up my situation and emotions that rainy night. I came home as the weekend was ending and as they say "time heals everything"

I also love 'Whispers of the North' which to me is a chant best sung to the rhythmic strokes of canoe paddles cutting the remote waters of some wilderness river. Having canoed some of the rivers Gord has, it is impossible not to be inspired by this fantastic country!

Yuri Amatnieks

[Barry Shanley]

"Now And Then" on Cold On The Shoulder is pretty good. I get to play my air guitar there.

[marc in maine]

"Now And Then" on Cold On The Shoulder is pretty good. I get to play my air guitar there.

[Cam68]

I have a favorite " Circle of Steel " . To me , it speaks of life and of what we give out and what we get back . It tells us , that our actions and our reasons don't always , give us what we need . " wheels of light , on a circle of steel , as we place , our bets on the great big wheel" . To me those words , and that song ; speak about the harsh realities that often haunt our lives . It's a song of what we want , what we settle for , and what we wind up with . " .... I believe that music mirrors life . That's the reason why songs move us so much .

[Cattphish]

I have a favorite " Circle of Steel " . To me , it speaks of life and of what we give out and what we get back . It tells us , that our actions and our reasons don't always , give us what we need . " wheels of light , on a circle of steel , as we place , our bets on the great big wheel" . To me those words , and that song ; speak about the harsh realities that often haunt our lives . It's a song of what we want , what we settle for , and what we wind up with . " .... I believe that music mirrors life . That's the reason why songs move us so much .

[Yandomm]

My first favorite was If You Could Read My Mind. Then after being in the Navy and riding out a couple of typhoons, ...Edmund Fitzgerald became my all time favorite song... by anyone. When he talks of "the wind in the wire made a tattle tell sound and a wave broke over the railing"... believe me.. that really brought back memories. I can't think of a better tribute to those poor souls who were lost in that incident.

[Peoria Fan]

My first favorite was If You Could Read My Mind. Then after being in the Navy and riding out a couple of typhoons, ...Edmund Fitzgerald became my all time favorite song... by anyone. When he talks of "the wind in the wire made a tattle tell sound and a wave broke over the railing"... believe me.. that really brought back memories. I can't think of a better tribute to those poor souls who were lost in that incident.

[Yandomm]

Oh yeah... Canadian Trilogy is another top favorite. I do a lot of his songs on karoke night. Trilogy is a grrreat ballad.

[Peoria Fan]

Oh yeah... Canadian Trilogy is another top favorite. I do a lot of his songs on karoke night. Trilogy is a grrreat ballad.

[Cathy]

If You Could Read My Mind is my favorite, too. I remember trying to play it on the guitar when I was a teenager (and the results weren't good!)
Then in the late '90s, I was listening to it one night, with guitar in hand, and it just came to me. I said, "Is that it? That's it? It's simple! Why did it take 25 years to figure it out?"
It's a good example of the distinct Lightfoot sound... little chord variations that add so much to his music,

[Jesse Joe]

"Seven Island Suite," has always been my favorite Lightfoot song.

[Jesse Joe]

"Seven Island Suite," has always been my favorite Lightfoot song.

[Gitchigumee]

I think for me it is Carefree Highway. I love that song, it stirs memories of a very happy and caretree time in my life, and of my first true love, who could have been and probably was my soul mate, but alas, we went our separate ways and life went on. However, whenever I hear that song, it brings me back to those days.

[geodeticman]

I've alaways loved IYCRMM, Beautiful, and Is There Anyone Home ?, but lately, as my relationship has grown even deeper with my wife of 26 years, I'd now say my current favourite is "Always on The Bright Side" - one of the new out-takes on Songbook disk 4 track 11 I believe. Haunting Melody, and so basic a background that highlights his voice, and beat.
geo Steve

[Bob Morrow]

Too many! I'm listening to Gord's Gold right now...found this site while looking up lyrics to make it easier to sing along, and to share with a friend. The song I looked up was Minstrel of the Dawn, but Carefree Highway is playing now, and oh, how I feel. Lightfoot's music composes a good deal of my personal soundtrack, from Affair on 8th Avenue to Don Quixote.

[Cam68]

Too many! I'm listening to Gord's Gold right now...found this site while looking up lyrics to make it easier to sing along, and to share with a friend. The song I looked up was Minstrel of the Dawn, but Carefree Highway is playing now, and oh, how I feel. Lightfoot's music composes a good deal of my personal soundtrack, from Affair on 8th Avenue to Don Quixote.

[edboyzz]

Beautiful
It reminds me of someone close to me.

[S. Wayne Dunaway]

Beautiful
It reminds me of someone close to me.

[edboyzz]

Beautiful
It reminds me of someone close to me.

[S. Wayne Dunaway]

Beautiful
It reminds me of someone close to me.

[Old Folkie]

Song for a Winter's Night, I Heard You Talking in Your Sleep, Shadows....

[julleken]

"Shadows" for its eeriness from, as Gord calls it, the "C Shape" he uses on his Martin.

[unbehaun]

"Shadows" for its eeriness from, as Gord calls it, the "C Shape" he uses on his Martin.

[Gitchigumee]

I've been listening to the CD Harmony all morning, and I must say, I really like a couple of the songs alot: Shellfish and Inspiration Lady, and the title song is growing on me more and more, I'm beginning to learn the words!

[Peter Bro10]

Okay, I'll play along for this one...
After much thought I've come up with the winner!!!!
"Lazy Mornin'", for the simple sense of peaceful feeling it gives each and every time I hear it!!! There is just something about it that settles my nerves a delivers a peaceful feeling.

[JohnStuardjr]

There are so many great Lightfoot tracks and among my all time faves are The Watchman's Gone, Seven Island Suite and Wherefore and Why. However, if I had to name an all time Lightfoot track it would be a song that never had much recognition in the US but was released as a single in the UK in 1978 - Daylight Katy.

It means a lot me and still I hear it occasionally on the odd radio staion in the UK notably Radio 2 and Radio Wales who happen to play some Lightfoot from time to time.

[sundownuk]

There are so many great Lightfoot tracks and among my all time faves are The Watchman's Gone, Seven Island Suite and Wherefore and Why. However, if I had to name an all time Lightfoot track it would be a song that never had much recognition in the US but was released as a single in the UK in 1978 - Daylight Katy.

It means a lot me and still I hear it occasionally on the odd radio staion in the UK notably Radio 2 and Radio Wales who happen to play some Lightfoot from time to time.

[SilverHeels]

Welcome to a real rarity. A UK Lighthead! There are not many of us on this side of the Pond, so a warm welcome to you from me!

[Gitchigumee]

Originally posted by sundownuk:
There are so many great Lightfoot tracks and among my all time faves are The Watchman's Gone, Seven Island Suite and Wherefore and Why. However, if I had to name an all time Lightfoot track it would be a song that never had much recognition in the US but was released as a single in the UK in 1978 - Daylight Katy.

It means a lot me and still I hear it occasionally on the odd radio staion in the UK notably Radio 2 and Radio Wales who happen to play some Lightfoot from time to time. Hey Sundown, I listen to Daylight Katy every day! It's a great song. Next time I listen to it, I'll think of you!

[patybear]

I'd have to say,'If You Could Read My Mind'is my favorite.Its the first Gordon Lightfoot song I ever heard.In case you're wondering,I'm old enough to remember when it was a current song,so I guess that gives you some idea of my age.

On a more personal note-theres something about that song(Don't ask me what)that just pulls at my heart . patybear

[TeftyJokip]

I am going to date myself but here is how I became to know Gordon Lightfoot. I was a senior in high school in 1970, graduated in January 1971, a little early. I had played guitar since maybe 5 or 6 and was into the "folk" stuff, Simon & Garfunkle, P, P & M, Dylan, etc. I was driving my 64 Dart one day and heard IYCRMM for the first time. I was so impressed with the words and vocalization. It was within my range and sounded like something that I could play. I bought the LP and played it over and over until I learned it. The entire album was full of trully great music. I played that song for a school talent show and won 1st Place. I am very sure it was the song choice and not my talent. I found some of his older stuff at a discount stgore and bought them all, all of the UA albums. When Summer Side of Life came out I bought it also. Well over the years I have had his stuff on vinyl, 8 tracks, casette, reel to reel and mow CD's. I have a complete collection of all his music on CD's and have it on my home and laptop computer. My business keeps me in a lot of motel rooms and he keeps me company. I am partial to a lot of the older stuff when Red Shea was with him. Favorite song? I have a hard time just picking a favorite album. Have to say IYCRMM, Don Quixote and Old Dan's Records as favorite albums. I love to play Ode to Big Blue, Edmond Fitzgerald, Yarmouth Castle, I'll Tag Along, Waiting For You, as well as many others.

[James B]

I am going to date myself but here is how I became to know Gordon Lightfoot. I was a senior in high school in 1970, graduated in January 1971, a little early. I had played guitar since maybe 5 or 6 and was into the "folk" stuff, Simon & Garfunkle, P, P & M, Dylan, etc. I was driving my 64 Dart one day and heard IYCRMM for the first time. I was so impressed with the words and vocalization. It was within my range and sounded like something that I could play. I bought the LP and played it over and over until I learned it. The entire album was full of trully great music. I played that song for a school talent show and won 1st Place. I am very sure it was the song choice and not my talent. I found some of his older stuff at a discount stgore and bought them all, all of the UA albums. When Summer Side of Life came out I bought it also. Well over the years I have had his stuff on vinyl, 8 tracks, casette, reel to reel and mow CD's. I have a complete collection of all his music on CD's and have it on my home and laptop computer. My business keeps me in a lot of motel rooms and he keeps me company. I am partial to a lot of the older stuff when Red Shea was with him. Favorite song? I have a hard time just picking a favorite album. Have to say IYCRMM, Don Quixote and Old Dan's Records as favorite albums. I love to play Ode to Big Blue, Edmond Fitzgerald, Yarmouth Castle, I'll Tag Along, Waiting For You, as well as many others.

[CanadaGirl38]

Dang! I'm older than you...... Picked up on Early Morning Rain when Peter, Paul and Mary released it at almost the same time the Kingston Trio did. The song flabergasted me it was so well written and PP&M do a nice job of it. Then they did For Lovin' Me. Being one who reads the writing credits on album I knew we had a live one here! It's a favorite because it opened the window. There are so many more favorites, I don't hand out the title of great song easilly but pointed out to my wife today that the Don Quiote album has 5 great songs on it in addition to the rest whci are all very good. That's a tough act to top, but he has on other albums.

[fezo]

Dang! I'm older than you...... Picked up on Early Morning Rain when Peter, Paul and Mary released it at almost the same time the Kingston Trio did. The song flabergasted me it was so well written and PP&M do a nice job of it. Then they did For Lovin' Me. Being one who reads the writing credits on album I knew we had a live one here! It's a favorite because it opened the window. There are so many more favorites, I don't hand out the title of great song easilly but pointed out to my wife today that the Don Quiote album has 5 great songs on it in addition to the rest whci are all very good. That's a tough act to top, but he has on other albums.

[asian teen porn.]

"Did She Mention My Name?"
I had been a GL fan for 10 years from "Sundown" and "If You Could Read My Mind" so I went in search of the earlier United Artists catalogue of work. This cut caught my attention through the subtle way that each trivial question asked ulitmately led to the real question that needed an answer: "Did I leave a true impression on her?" We have all walked away from a relationship that we regret, and Gordon so eloquently reminds us of the mistake we feel we made sometime in the past.

[Alan Olson]

"Did She Mention My Name?"
I had been a GL fan for 10 years from "Sundown" and "If You Could Read My Mind" so I went in search of the earlier United Artists catalogue of work. This cut caught my attention through the subtle way that each trivial question asked ulitmately led to the real question that needed an answer: "Did I leave a true impression on her?" We have all walked away from a relationship that we regret, and Gordon so eloquently reminds us of the mistake we feel we made sometime in the past.

[DJ in MJ]

Great choice, Alan. DSMMN stands on its own very well, but I also love it on the tail of For Lovin' Me. The two songs are complete opposites in the protagonist's attitude, and the effect is wonderful!

[Gitchigumee]

Favorite Old Song: Carefree Highway
Favorite Newer Song: Inspiration Lady
Future Favorite: To Be Announced

Has anyone heard whether Gord's been writing any new stuff lately?

[Yuri]

Originally posted by Cathy:
quote:Originally posted by 1010718:
As many of you have stated, a favorite GL song is just too hard to pin down. But one that haunts me is, and I'm not sure I have the title right, but the oft repeated line "I heard you talking in your sleep..." is the one I would pick if I had to. It used to take me to my knees every time I heard it, back when I was going through a rough patch.

Besides the GL-ness of it, one thing that I thoroughly enjoy about this song is the men's chorus in the background. I'm just fascinated by them.

Is there someone else out there that knows what I'm talking about... Oh, that's a great song. It's called Talkin' In Your Sleep. According to Rick Haynes, the guys singing in the background are saying, "Take a potato... take a potato... take a potato...
I know, it doesn't make a bit of sense.

Does anyone else hear, "Take a potato"? [/QUOTE]

[1010718]

Originally posted by Cathy:
quote:Originally posted by 1010718:
As many of you have stated, a favorite GL song is just too hard to pin down. But one that haunts me is, and I'm not sure I have the title right, but the oft repeated line "I heard you talking in your sleep..." is the one I would pick if I had to. It used to take me to my knees every time I heard it, back when I was going through a rough patch.

Besides the GL-ness of it, one thing that I thoroughly enjoy about this song is the men's chorus in the background. I'm just fascinated by them.

Is there someone else out there that knows what I'm talking about... Oh, that's a great song. It's called Talkin' In Your Sleep. According to Rick Haynes, the guys singing in the background are saying, "Take a potato... take a potato... take a potato...
I know, it doesn't make a bit of sense.

Does anyone else hear, "Take a potato"? [/QUOTE]

[Paul Farnham]

Am I the only aging picker who's thought he'd like "Minstrel of the Dawn" played at his (inevitable but not yet imminent) memorial service?

[charlene]

Originally posted by Gitchigumee:
Favorite Old Song: Carefree Highway
Favorite Newer Song: Inspiration Lady
Future Favorite: To Be Announced

Has anyone heard whether Gord's been writing any new stuff lately? Someone asked him that backstage at Massey...he said 'nope.'

Char

[charlene]

Originally posted by Gitchigumee:
Favorite Old Song: Carefree Highway
Favorite Newer Song: Inspiration Lady
Future Favorite: To Be Announced

Has anyone heard whether Gord's been writing any new stuff lately? Someone asked him that backstage at Massey...he said 'nope.'

Char

[TolpanTesterThree]

It's really hard to choose, even though I've heard only 11 or so of his songs, because I've seriously listened to the same CD hundreds of times since I was very young. I've grown up listening to Gord.

My favourite line is "Lake Huron rolls, Superior sings in the rooms of her ice water mansion. Old Michigan steams like a young man's dreams; the islands and bays are for sportsmen. Farther below, Lake Ontario takes in what Lake Erie can send her." I live rather close to the Great Lakes, so they hold a special place in my heart, and this is the best, most beautiful way I think anyone's conveyed them.

My favourite song to think about it "Too Many Clues in This Room" because it is so puzzling and can mean just about anything.

My favourite song overall, just to listen to, is "Race Among the Ruins", because it's simply such a great work.

[Yooper89]

It's really hard to choose, even though I've heard only 11 or so of his songs, because I've seriously listened to the same CD hundreds of times since I was very young. I've grown up listening to Gord.

My favourite line is "Lake Huron rolls, Superior sings in the rooms of her ice water mansion. Old Michigan steams like a young man's dreams; the islands and bays are for sportsmen. Farther below, Lake Ontario takes in what Lake Erie can send her." I live rather close to the Great Lakes, so they hold a special place in my heart, and this is the best, most beautiful way I think anyone's conveyed them.

My favourite song to think about it "Too Many Clues in This Room" because it is so puzzling and can mean just about anything.

My favourite song overall, just to listen to, is "Race Among the Ruins", because it's simply such a great work.

[JennyLoraam]

I've been a Lightfoot fan since the early 70's, but just in passing... you know, all the hits. Since I've married a Lighhead, I've gotten to know the body of his work in much more detail.

My favorite song is Restless. The note that plays in the back of the song just pulls me. I went to look a the lyrics to pull out a line or two to post here, but I can't. It's the entire song.

There's a kind of a restless feeling and it pulls me from within
It sets my senses reeling and my wheels begin to spin
In the quietude of winter you can hear the wild geese cry
And I will always love that sound until the day I die

There's a plain and a simple answer to each and every quest
From every quiet dance who might be a special guest
In a movie made for TV or a late night interview
You might even find them on the Young and the Restless too

Do ya get that restless feelin' when you hear a whistle blast
Like an echo from the past
Of an old engine flyin' down a road that's ironcast

The lake is blue, the sky is gray, the leaves have turned to gold
The wild goose will be on her way, the weather's much too cold
When the muskie and the old trout too have all gone down to rest
We will be returning to the things that we love best

Do ya get that restless yearning when you think about your dad
And the scrimshaw that he had
Of an old schooner rovin' 'neath a sky that's ironclad

There's a kind of a restless feeling and it catches you off guard
As we gaze off at the distance through the trees in my back yard
I can feel that restless yearning of those geese as off they roam
Then trade that for a warm bed and a place I can call home

Will ya get that restless yearning when you hear the wicked blast
Of a spectre from the past
Of a cold diesel rollin' down a road that's built to last

Still I get that restless feelin' when I hear a whistle blast
See an image from the past
Of an old schooner flyin' down a sky that's overcast


My Lighthead and I spend untold hours out exploring as much of the world as we can. It's usually a short trip out of the city, but it's always that one note, calling throughout that song, that pulls me, every time.

[hiway songs]

I've been a Lightfoot fan since the early 70's, but just in passing... you know, all the hits. Since I've married a Lighhead, I've gotten to know the body of his work in much more detail.

My favorite song is Restless. The note that plays in the back of the song just pulls me. I went to look a the lyrics to pull out a line or two to post here, but I can't. It's the entire song.

There's a kind of a restless feeling and it pulls me from within
It sets my senses reeling and my wheels begin to spin
In the quietude of winter you can hear the wild geese cry
And I will always love that sound until the day I die

There's a plain and a simple answer to each and every quest
From every quiet dance who might be a special guest
In a movie made for TV or a late night interview
You might even find them on the Young and the Restless too

Do ya get that restless feelin' when you hear a whistle blast
Like an echo from the past
Of an old engine flyin' down a road that's ironcast

The lake is blue, the sky is gray, the leaves have turned to gold
The wild goose will be on her way, the weather's much too cold
When the muskie and the old trout too have all gone down to rest
We will be returning to the things that we love best

Do ya get that restless yearning when you think about your dad
And the scrimshaw that he had
Of an old schooner rovin' 'neath a sky that's ironclad

There's a kind of a restless feeling and it catches you off guard
As we gaze off at the distance through the trees in my back yard
I can feel that restless yearning of those geese as off they roam
Then trade that for a warm bed and a place I can call home

Will ya get that restless yearning when you hear the wicked blast
Of a spectre from the past
Of a cold diesel rollin' down a road that's built to last

Still I get that restless feelin' when I hear a whistle blast
See an image from the past
Of an old schooner flyin' down a sky that's overcast


My Lighthead and I spend untold hours out exploring as much of the world as we can. It's usually a short trip out of the city, but it's always that one note, calling throughout that song, that pulls me, every time.

[Borderstone]

A most favorite off of "East Of Midnight" is "I'll Tag Along". I love those lyrics and the overall message & mood.

Best of all though,there are in existence "acoustic" versions that I hear are even better than that 1986 track! :cool:

Oh and I just happened to notice..post #800 for this topic! :cool: Wow! :eek:

Glad I got the day off! :D

[robthegotomanhome]

Originally posted by Florian:
What is your favorite Lightfoot Song & Why?

(topic originated by Wes Steele)


[This message has been edited by Florian (edited February 26, 2000).]

[mynoah]

Originally posted by Florian:
What is your favorite Lightfoot Song & Why?

(topic originated by Wes Steele)


[This message has been edited by Florian (edited February 26, 2000).]

[micglor]

The fact that "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" brings me to tears every single time I hear it (and has for the last thirty years) should qualify it as my favorite! There is also a rather obscure song from early on that I especially like but I don't recall the title. It was very short, less than a minute, and the lyrics were to the effect of "it would take a full-blooded Indian heart to take what you dish out and I'm only 1/8 Cherokee." Sorry if that's not accurate, but I haven't heard it in years. I always thought it was really cool. Actually, I'm hard-pressed to pick a favorite, unless of course it's the "Edmund Fitzgerald." A gallant tribute to gallant men!

[charlene]

"it would take a full-blooded Indian heart to take what you dish out and I'm only 1/8 Cherokee." [/QB]hmmmm.... can't say I know of a Lightfoot tune with lyrics in any way similar to those..

[charlene]

"it would take a full-blooded Indian heart to take what you dish out and I'm only 1/8 Cherokee." [/QB]hmmmm.... can't say I know of a Lightfoot tune with lyrics in any way similar to those..

[Jim W.]

Originally posted by Florian:
What is your favorite Lightfoot Song & Why?
Did she mention my name, because It was so appropriate to me at one time and I have not forgoten.
(topic originated by Wes Steele)


[This message has been edited by Florian (edited February 26, 2000).]

[Jim W.]

Originally posted by Florian:
What is your favorite Lightfoot Song & Why?
Did she mention my name, because It was so appropriate to me at one time and I have not forgoten. Won't you say hello from someone, there'll be no need to explain. doesn't get much better than this, does it? :) :) :)
(topic originated by Wes Steele)


[This message has been edited by Florian (edited February 26, 2000).]

[geodeticman]

A new favourite of mine that I've been listening to A LOT lately is Restless, from the WFY album.

As so many have commented on it similarly, its melody is haunting, and the lyrics are quintessential GL outdoors-feel.

I find my self setting the CD in the car on repeat on Restless for many times over often. I do find the much discussed "Ring Them Bells" written by Dylan on WFY right after Restless to be a beautiful song as well. A fitting song for GL to pay another tribute to one of his mentors early on with.

I'd still have to say my all-time favourite, outside of his top 5 or so hits from the 70's, would be "That Same Old Obsession", from ODR. His voice was a well-oiled machine in this song (that didn't come out quite right, but you know what I mean; vibrato, clear, strong, hale and hearty and all that good stuff :) ).

In a similar vein, the songs: Now and Then from COTS, Tattoo from Salute, and I definately agree with Borderstone on "I'll Tag Along" from EOM.

And yup, I too have heard what I'd say is the more acoustic version done solo in concert, along with EOM the song itself done same way, and they are magnificent.

To further obfuscate my allready blown "one favourite song" premise LOL, I'd add that his most fascinating song to me, that gets a lot of repeat action still by me, is: "Is There Anyone Home" from Sundown.

I know I have waxed enthusiastic on this one so many times I'll not repeat the same thoughts, given that I even devoted a whole thread to it; but aside from the others that are favourites of mine for reasons of melody, lyrics, or both above, this song hangs in memory for so long each time I play it as a distinguishing characteristic.

Despite not being a relative masterpiece of his by comparison, it still leaves one wondering about the meanings, metaphors, and meanderings in the song that are so beautifully underscored by the soaring *REAL* string section that make you want to inhale the aroma of autumn leaves, or pine trees after a rain, or whatever sensory orts that come to mind when one listens to this song. It is absolutely captivating to me.

OK those are my non-sequiter GL musical thoughts for the day that I hope strike a chord in someone :) I haven't posted much at all in the last two months, and it feels good to stretch my GL legs a bit here, so thanks for bearing with me. I've missed all yuse guys :)

geo Steve

[brink-]

Hi Geo Steve, long time gone....hope all is well.
I agree with the Now and Then - fabulous song.
Don't be a stranger, come back often. "Is There Anyone Home"? we are!

[Gitchigumee]

I have been itching to buy another Lightfoot CD, but I'm having a very difficult time deciding which one to buy next. So far I have: Gord's Gold, Complete Greatest Hits, United Artists Collection & Harmony.

Help!

[Gitchigumee]

I ordered Sundown. Patience is not one of my virtues.

[Fitzy]

pick my favorite song ? that's like picking my favorite child . It's rainy day people . I do have ot say I have a limited exposure to his music though I am working on getting on other cds.

[dragon_fly]

pick my favorite song ? that's like picking my favorite child . It's rainy day people . I do have ot say I have a limited exposure to his music though I am working on getting on other cds.

[lokenoch]

I can't come up with a favorite,too many, But I will always associate Edmond Fitzgerald with my first prgnancy. I loved that song and I played it alot the fall of 1976.
And Sundown,,,, I remember skipping days in high school to go have a little fun with a boyfriend.... "Getting lost in your loving is your first mistake". LOL...

[LesLee]

I can't come up with a favorite,too many, But I will always associate Edmond Fitzgerald with my first prgnancy. I loved that song and I played it alot the fall of 1976.
And Sundown,,,, I remember skipping days in high school to go have a little fun with a boyfriend.... "Getting lost in your loving is your first mistake". LOL...

[Germany76]

Sorry, but I have only managed to ascertain my top three songs from my top 100.
They are: Race Among The Ruins, Summer Side Of Life and 14 Karat Gold.
They would be equal favourite and there would be another ten that would be equal second favourite.
Ben

[lokenoch]

Sorry, but I have only managed to ascertain my top three songs from my top 100.
They are: Race Among The Ruins, Summer Side Of Life and 14 Karat Gold.
They would be equal favourite and there would be another ten that would be equal second favourite.
Ben

[louisemnnpls]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by Yooper89:
It's really hard to choose, even though I've heard only 11 or so of his songs, because I've seriously listened to the same CD hundreds of times since I was very young. I've grown up listening to Gord.

Yooper89,
Are you a real bonafide "Yooper"? Just wondering, as I was born and raised in the UP of MI.

As for my favorite GL songs, haven't posted any until now, as they change from day to day and season to season. But, they do include, "Song for a Winter's Night", "Canadian Railroad Trilogy",
"If You could Read MY Mind", "The Wreck of (the Edmund Fitzgerald)", "Sit Down Young Stranger",
"Yarmouth Castle", "Pussywillows Cattails".....
there are just SO many! There isn't one that I don't like.

Right now, today, it might be "Sit Down Young Stranger" as we have not seen our 19 year old grandson since Thanksgiving, and he is much on my mind.

[Catherine Kunz]

My favorite GL song with out a doubt is "If You Could Read My Mind". This is the first song of his I ever heard and between the voice and guitar I was hooked. I was in my teens and and my father had just died. I was going through all the emotional trials personal relationships at that age can bring. The lyrics cut right to the heart of things and as an emotionally bleeding teen I was the "Hero" that "often fails". Later came "Sundown", "Carefree Highway", "The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald" (I had it on 45 rpm vinyl!). I am like so many other fans, there are noneof his songs that I don't like.

It will always be "If You Could Read My Mind" that transports me back to a time when I needed to hear someone else going through the same trials as I. I still get misty eyed and remember a different time of life when I hear it by surprise on the radio. Thanks Gordon, for bringing me through it all.

[SGT]

My favorite GL song with out a doubt is "If You Could Read My Mind". This is the first song of his I ever heard and between the voice and guitar I was hooked. I was in my teens and and my father had just died. I was going through all the emotional trials personal relationships at that age can bring. The lyrics cut right to the heart of things and as an emotionally bleeding teen I was the "Hero" that "often fails". Later came "Sundown", "Carefree Highway", "The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald" (I had it on 45 rpm vinyl!). I am like so many other fans, there are noneof his songs that I don't like.

It will always be "If You Could Read My Mind" that transports me back to a time when I needed to hear someone else going through the same trials as I. I still get misty eyed and remember a different time of life when I hear it by surprise on the radio. Thanks Gordon, for bringing me through it all.

[bjm7777]

Fav song, boy that is tough. I believe it to be for me "The Circle is Small" that song came to me at a point in my life where I could not express to anyone what I was feeling or going through. I heard that song and realized it did not matter what anyone else thought, but that someone out there in the universe got it. That person was Mr. Lightfoot, and he got it way before me. So much solice for me in that song. Now a few years later I listen to it and think wow thank you for having the words that even the closest people to my heart did not have for me. It is like close enough to let your mind go there in a few private moments, but not some thing you can't explain to another human being. That is true music genius helping people and not even knowing who they are. Your message is so sincere and real there are others in the universe who get you, and you don't even know you.

[Fitzy]

Fav song, boy that is tough. I believe it to be for me "The Circle is Small" that song came to me at a point in my life where I could not express to anyone what I was feeling or going through. I heard that song and realized it did not matter what anyone else thought, but that someone out there in the universe got it. That person was Mr. Lightfoot, and he got it way before me. So much solice for me in that song. Now a few years later I listen to it and think wow thank you for having the words that even the closest people to my heart did not have for me. It is like close enough to let your mind go there in a few private moments, but not some thing you can't explain to another human being. That is true music genius helping people and not even knowing who they are. Your message is so sincere and real there are others in the universe who get you, and you don't even know you.

[fkafl]

This is an extremely difficult one to properly post on because there is such a HUGE repertoire of Lightfoot's songs. Be that as it may, I have to say that my favorite song has to be "I'll Do Anything" from "Shadows", which is also my favorite album of his. I first heard Lightfoot's music on the radio in 1966 thereabouts, when I was a kid in elementary school - a song called "I'm Not Sayin'". I was hooked.
On "Harmony", the title track is very nice, but my favorite there is "River of Light".

[bjm7777]

This is an extremely difficult one to properly post on because there is such a HUGE repertoire of Lightfoot's songs. Be that as it may, I have to say that my favorite song has to be "I'll Do Anything" from "Shadows", which is also my favorite album of his. I first heard Lightfoot's music on the radio in 1966 thereabouts, when I was a kid in elementary school - a song called "I'm Not Sayin'". I was hooked.
On "Harmony", the title track is very nice, but my favorite there is "River of Light".

[B45-12]

I think that part of the brilliance of GL's music is that he can express all the feelings we have at different periods of our life. When I was rafting, I loved the sea songs. When I was dating, it was his relationship-type songs. Now, just last night, "A Painter Passing Through" knocked me off my feet. It's expresses exactly the different seasons and feelings of my life. So right now, that's my favorite. Rock on, Gord! Hope Austin gives you a great welcome!

[Madeleine]

I think that part of the brilliance of GL's music is that he can express all the feelings we have at different periods of our life. When I was rafting, I loved the sea songs. When I was dating, it was his relationship-type songs. Now, just last night, "A Painter Passing Through" knocked me off my feet. It's expresses exactly the different seasons and feelings of my life. So right now, that's my favorite. Rock on, Gord! Hope Austin gives you a great welcome!

[Jennifer]

I agree, Sheryl from North Cali. Last summer and fall I played so much GL it was like the "soundtrack" for that period of my life. While on roadtrips I listened to those songs about wanderlust, while by the great lakes we listened to songs about the high seas, when fall rolled around, Sunday Concert seemed to compliment that atmosphere best when its time to start relecting inward.

And can't forget, last February, I experienced utter bliss listening to Spanish Moss and Miguel while overlooking the azure blue ocean from the balcony of our resort in Cancun :)

[B45-12]

Totally forgotten about Spanish Moss! I can see my reacquaintance period is gonna cost me a bundle! One more day, Jenn, and we're free for 48 whole hours! ;)

[Madeleine]

Totally forgotten about Spanish Moss! I can see my reacquaintance period is gonna cost me a bundle! One more day, Jenn, and we're free for 48 whole hours! ;)

[Shutup and Deal, I'm Losin']

For the time being, my favorite Gord song is Rainbow Trout. One of the best melodies ever written by any artist.

(After 6 years of being buried, I thought I would bring this topic back up, as there have been a number of new people to join the board since then :) ).

[paskatefan]

It's very hard to limit it to just one song, but if I absolutely have to, it would be "Circle of Steel." I love recorder flute, and the melody is so gorgeous!

Other faves - Sea of Tranquility, In My Fashion, Ghosts of Cape Horn, Dream Street Rose, Summertime Dream, Seven Island Suite, Hiway Songs, The Soul is the Rock, A Tree too Weak to Stand, Daylight Katy, Morning Glory, Approaching Lavender, a Passing Ship, Whispers of the North, If Children Had Wings, Slide on Over ...

[Dave, Melbourne,Australia]

Shutup and Deal,

Thanks for resurrecting this thread after 6 years. I discovered the Corfid website 5-and-a-half years ago.

Under another thread, I listed my favourite Lightfoot songs as "Shadows", "A Lesson In Love", "Restless", "Much To My Surprise" and "End Of All Time". I guess I stick by that list today. The very-original melody and chorus of "Shadows" captured my imagination from the first time I heard it. Gord's singing, the musical arrangement and the band members' performances were never better. I was thrilled to see "Shadows" performed at the one Lightfoot concert I managed to attend (2008 in Wisconsin). I also love Tony Rice's bluegrass cover version.

[JohninCt.]

I guess I would have to say that it changes as life goes on. I really liked "Early Morning Rain" way back when Ian & Sylvia did it, from then on there have been constant changes in my life, and Gordon has written songs all along that fit in as my favorites as each album came out. I have bought his records since they first came out here in the US. A few songs stand out, as to feeling what I felt at the time, such as "Looking At The Rain". and it stands out for me as superb in all ways. "Spanish Moss" is another, what a picture it puts out. "Summer Side Of Life" ahhh yes. Just too many songs thru all these years, to be just one. The man can see deeply, and can sing it all the right way.

[charlene]

after last night in Buffalo and another stellar concert and an amazing and breathtaking IYCRMM and a thunderous prolonged standing ovation IYCRMM has to be number 1.